All-ACCAC/All-Region I/All-American Players
| All-ACCAC/All-Region I | Year |
|---|---|
| Zach Lanman (2nd Team) All-ACCAC | 2025 |
| Bryan Perez (Honorable Mention) All-ACCAC | 2025 |
| Brody Donovan (2nd Team) All-ACCAC | 2025 |
| Zakari Smith (2nd Team) All-Region | 2024 |
| Cody Helmhout (Honorable Mention) All-Region | 2024 |
| Fariel Corrales (1st Team) All-Region DII (1st team) | 2023 |
| Gabriel Gutierrez Alapizco (Honorable Mention) All-Region DII (2nd team) | 2023 |
| Adnan Elaqad (1st team) All-Region DII (1st team) | 2022 |
| Kayden Burns (2nd team) All-Region DII (1st team) | 2022 |
| Marco Martinez (2nd team) All-Region DII (2nd team) | 2022 |
| Isaiah Garay (2nd team) | 2021 |
| Season cancele due to COVID-19 | 2020 |
| Jesus Garcia (1st team) | 2019 |
| Andres Hernandez (2nd team) | 2019 |
| Moises Durazo (Hon. Men.) | 2019 |
| Preston Grayson (Hon. Men.) | 2019 |
| Danny Bacca (1st team) | 2018 |
| Morgan Barta (2nd team) | 2018 |
| Bryant Sanchez (2nd team) | 2018 |
| Jesus Garcia (Hon. Men.) | 2018 |
| Benji Delgadillo (1st team) | 2015 |
| Obedd Fuentes (Hon. Men.) | 2015 |
| Ari Sanchez (1st team) | 2014 |
| Brian Perea (2nd team) | 2014 |
| Danny Wichman (Hon. Men.) | 2014 |
| Kendyl Day (1st team) | 2013 |
| Luke Bunjovac (2nd team) | 2013 |
| Danny Molina (Honorable Mention) | 2013 |
| Bo Bechtel (1st team) | 2012 |
| Brennan Redd (2nd team) | 2012 |
| Michael Markette (Honorable Mention) | 2012 |
| Michael Markette (2nd team) | 2011 |
| Ricardo Lopez (2nd team) | 2011 |
| Miguel Romero (Honorable Mention) | 2011 |
| Justin Incarnati (GK) (1st Team) | 2010 |
| Bashiru Ali (1st Team) | 2009 |
| Brian Hernandez (2nd Team) | 2009 |
| Ross Wood (Honorable Mention) | 2008 |
| Nick Auditore (1st Team) | 2007 |
| Reid Schmitt (1st Team) | 2007 |
| Derrick Otton (Honorable Mention) | 2007 |
| Nick Auditore (1st Team) 1st Team All-American | 2006 |
| Reid Schmitt (2nd Team) | 2006 |
| Josh Chavez (1st Team) | 2005 |
| Jake O'Haver (2nd Team) | 2005 |
| Chris Francis (2nd Team) | 2005 |
| Gabe Murillo (2nd Team) | 2005 |
| Steven Gloria (2nd Team) | 2004 |
| Gabe Murillo (Honorable Mention) | 2004 |
| Adam Baxter (1st Team) 1st Team All-American | 2003 |
| Ricky Fetherston (1st Team) | 2003 |
| Nagui Sabbagh (2nd Team) | 2003 |
| Ben Pullen (2nd Team) | 2003 |
| Patrick Brown (Honorable Mention) | 2003 |
| Nagui Sabbagh (1st Team) | 2002 |
| Adam Baxter (1st Team) | 2002 |
| Jonathan Peters (2nd Team) | 2002 |
| Patrick Brown (2nd Team) | 2002 |
| Sergio Torrecillas (2nd Team) | 2002 |
| Jamon Lifsey (1st Team) Player of the Year, 1st Team All-American | 2001 |
| Alex Grecu (1st Team) Honorable Mention All-American | 2001 |
| Nick Nelson (2nd Team) | 2001 |
| Matt Cameron (2nd Team) | 2001 |
| Eric Tate (2nd Team) | 2001 |
| Alex Grecu (1st Team) | 2000 |
| Chris Marshburn (1st Team) | 2000 |
| Pat Cosgrove (2nd Team) | 2000 |
| Clint Crockett (2nd Team) | 2000 |
| Eric Bass (1st Team) Player of the Year, 1st Team All-American | 1999 |
| Jeff Carter (1st Team) | 1999 |
| Jaime Miranda (1st Team) | 1999 |
| KC O'Haver (2nd Team) | 1999 |
| Jared Polivka (1st Team) Honorable Mention All-American | 1998 |
| Lucas Coehlo (1st Team) | 1998 |
| Mark Wilson (2nd Team) | 1998 |
| Johnny Marusic (2nd Team) | 1998 |
| Johnny Marusic (1st Team) 2nd Team All-American | 1997 |
| Jared Polivka (1st Team) | 1997 |
| Lucas Coehlo (2nd Team) | 1997 |
| Ryan Love (2nd Team) | 1997 |
| Sean Mockbee (2nd Team) | 1997 |
| Manuel Coehlo (1st Team) Player of the Year, 1st Team All-American | 1996 |
| Tyson Breinholt (2nd Team) | 1996 |
| Angel Marin (2nd Team) | 1996 |
| Scott Smedsted (2nd Team) | 1996 |
| Jason Skinner (Honorable Mention) | 1996 |
| Dwayne Gbelia (1st Team) ACCAC All-Star | 1995 |
| Ben Moore (1st Team) 1st Team All-American ACCAC All-Star | 1995 |
| Mike Nordstrom (2nd Team) ACCAC All-Star | 1995 |
| Mike Wesolek (2nd Team) ACCAC All-Star | 1995 |
| Scott Smedsted (2nd Team) ACCAC All-Star | 1995 |
| Ash Greer (Honorable Mention) | 1995 |
| Mikael Nordstrom ACCAC All-Star | 1994 |
| Jason Self ACCAC All-Star | 1994 |
| Ben Moore ACCAC All-Star | 1994 |
| Josh Jacobsen ACCAC All-Star | 1994 |
| Evan Curry ACCAC All-Star | 1992 |
| Oscar Lopez ACCAC All-Star | 1992 |
| Rich Esperti ACCAC All-Star | 1991 |
| James Gill ACCAC All-Star | 1991 |
| Donny Deutsch ACCAC All-Star | 1991 |
| Mike Larkin ACCAC All-Star | 1991 |
| Guiseppe Monteleone ACCAC All-Star | 1990 |
| Mike Mahannah ACCAC All-Star | 1990 |
| Rich Esperti ACCAC All-Star | 1990 |
| Mike Larkin ACCAC All-Star | 1990 |
| Mike Driscoll ACCAC All-Star | 1990 |
| Robert Saveski ACCAC All-Star | 1989 |
| Mike Driscoll ACCAC All-Star | 1989 |
| Andrew Snow ACCAC All-Star | 1989 |
| Louie Percic ACCAC All-Star | 1988 |
| Steve Schleim ACCAC All-Star | 1988 |
| Ryan Harper ACCAC All-Star | 1988 |
| Danny Sanchez ACCAC All-Star | 1988 |
| Rob Sahm ACCAC All-Star | 1988 |
| Mark Ireland ACCAC All-Star | 1988 |
| Dave Heckert ACCAC All-Star | 1987 |
| J.D. Daniels ACCAC All-Star | 1987 |
| Dean Tonks ACCAC All-Star | 1987 |
| Eric Weikert Player of the Year, 1st Team All-American, ACCAC All-Star | 1987 |
| Rob Sahm ACCAC All-Star | 1987 |
| Steve Schleim ACCAC All-Star | 1987 |
| Warren Gesin ACCAC All-Star | 1987 |
| Louie Percic ACCAC All-Star | 1987 |